Night At The Play Party 😈

My complete experience at an open sex party in Mexico City, and the unexpected lessons it taught me.

Night At The Play Party 😈
Logan Weaver from Unsplash

The photo above is not from the party itself, but very much matches the vibe.

This article is the extended version of the soon-to-be-published “How to Attend A Play Party
And Actually Enjoy It 😏,” with absolutely all the details. Enjoy!

On a Saturday night in November, I headed to my 4th play party ever. I stepped out of my Uber into the fresh night air and reached the gate of a barely marked house in Las Lomas, one of the fanciest neighborhoods in Mexico City. It was 10:40pm, and I was relieved there had been so little traffic: I had to attend a mandatory consent discussion at 11pm, before the real party got started.

Still, I was nervous as heck. My first three play party experiences in New York City had ended in vomiting, shame, and disaster. I’d gotten way too drunk way too quickly, and taken a giant edible I shouldn’t have, in an attempt to avoid my feelings, which ended up majorly backfiring. I’d had to shuffle myself quickly into getaway Ubers soon after I arrived before I made a total fool of myself. Would this play party turn out to be just as bad? Would my PTSD (caused by a nasty sexual assault I experienced five years ago) be triggered again? There was only one way to find out. I punched the secret code into the pinpad. The gate buzzed open, and I stepped inside.

Like many of my good, sexy stories, this one started on the kink app, Feeld. I got invited to this party kind of by accident. I had been on and off Feeld for years, but something made me redownload it. Things were finally turning around for the better in my life. I was getting over depression from my grandmother's death and going into debt. I was about to leave Mexico City for a trip that would last three and a half months. This was my last weekend in the city, and part of me wanted to do something crazy. I also hadn’t had penetrative sex in over a year, and I had only had one partner who ate me out about six months ago, and I was tiptoeing on the particularly horny cusp between the end of my period and ovulating, leaving me extra energized. Most of all, I have been numbing myself by scrolling on the internet for so long that I needed to put myself out there.

After a couple of matches on Feeld, I stumbled across an acquaintance from my circle of Tuluminati friends in Mexico City, whom I’ll call Matt. Matt, as far as I knew, was in an open marriage, but the few times I had hung out with him, I got the sense he was an intriguing weirdo. Plus, I thought he was cute. However, he had never seemed interested in me. He had the creative, psychedelic air of a regular Burning Man attendee, a group of people I regularly hung out with in Mexico City but deny being identified with. When I came across Matt’s profile on Feeld, I thought: fuck it! I swiped right. We matched a day later, and this is the gist of our conversation:

Matt: Hi

Me: Hi

Matt: How are you?

Me: I’m good. I just finished playing pickleball. What’s up?

Matt: Fun. I play padel. I’m going to a play party tonight.

Me: A play party? Is that an open invite?

Matt: Text this guy. [Shares guy’s phone number.] It’s going to be a big one. About 60-70 people.

These messages happened over the course of a few hours, between me going to pickleball and back, and feeling all the sad, giddy anxiety of a guy I might be interested in not messaging me back promptly. I now had to make a decision. Matt had, indeed, invited me to this play party. I did find him attractive, and I was potentially curious to hook up with him. But if I was going to go to this party, I also didn’t want to anchor myself on the expectation that we would hook up, or even that he would be attracted to me. I assured myself that if we didn’t make out, I wasn’t going to beat myself up about it. The success of my night would not hinge on him (and that turned out to be a great decision). Still, I had a birthday party to attend earlier in the night, and a bunch of other saying-goodbye things planned. Should I go or not? It was also a costume party, the week after Halloween, so there was that to consider.

Still unsure whether to go, I got dressed up in an outfit I thought might be appropriate. It wasn’t a Halloween costume, but I did wear something that was both striking and comfortable and made me feel sexy. I showed up in all red: deep-red lipstick, boots, a handbag, and a dress with metal buttons down the middle that showed off my curves.

When I got to the Ecobici station to hop on a bike to go to the birthday party, I checked out the play party’s website. It had lots of flashing emojis and text in capital letters, and a giant ticker clock that would expire in the next 45 minutes if I didn’t buy my ticket on time. I decided to wait for a little while longer.

The flyer for the play party
The actual flyer for the event, with all the identifiable details covered!

As I put on my helmet at the Ecobici station, I heard a couple of people walking down the street. Of course, I was living in Condesa, so it wasn’t completely unusual to hear someone speak English. But this  woman had a West London accent, very close to where I am from. And she seemed to be about 70 years old. And I thought to myself: one day I’ll be too old to go to one of these play parties. I may never be this hot or this young ever again. In fact, when I ended up at the play party, there were plenty of slightly older couples around her age. So I maybe took the age thing too seriously. Still, I think there is something to be said about the fact that this body in this lifetime isn’t going to last forever. Plus, I needed something to write about on my blog.

My friends at the birthday party told me I looked great, which was a lovely stroke of the ego. In my Uber on the way to the party, I bought my ticket and texted the guy, Manny, who was hosting the play party. I joined a WhatsApp group of a couple hundred people of the play community around the world, and Manny encouraged me to introduce myself in the group. I decided not to do that; I’m not sure why. During this journey, I remember we drove past a shop for children’s christening outfits that was closed for the night. I chuckled to myself. The store itself looked so innocent and somewhat religious. Here I was, about to do things that might be considered immoral to the customers of that store.

When I arrived at the house, a couple of girls were chatting in Spanish outside, and I found a bathroom next to the garage, where I freshened up. Unfortunately, I was in the middle of a pretty nasty hemorrhoid flare, which is maybe TMI, and sadly meant that I would not be doing any butt stuff. I was also feeling pretty nervous, but I made some big poses in the mirror to try to beef up my confidence. I just had to trust the process and let things play out.

I entered the house through the side door and entered the small kitchen. Inside were two short, plump women wearing corsets, black lingerie, and hosiery. There were also two Mexican men and Matt, my match from Feeld, who was wearing a bear onesie. I felt extremely awkward, but I was not quite ready to explore the rest of the house, so I got chatting. One of the Mexican guys was dressed up in a dinosaur costume, and the other was wearing a hoodie.

Things started to get weird pretty quickly. Another girl entered the room holding a colorful leather whip with tassels, and she offered to spank or whip someone. I declined, but Matt agreed immediately. So before I had hardly walked in the door, Matt bent over in his bear onesie, and I watched him get whipped on his ass right in front of me. As someone who is more submissive myself, I wasn’t that turned on watching him, much less because I was a bit shocked. The Mexican guy in the dinosaur onesie was cuter to begin with, but he now had the two girls in the corsets on either of his arms, and they were already making out. I turned to the other Mexican guy in the hoodie and started to make polite conversation. Mostly just because I felt awkward.

The guy in the hoodie’s name was Diego. He seemed interesting, intelligent, and if anything, pretty nerdy. Just how I like them. He had glasses, long curly hair, and tattoos. He met my threshold of attractiveness, but I wasn’t overly enamored with him when I first met him. He seemed like the kind of person I could become more attracted to over time, if we got to know each other more intimately.

We didn’t have any time to explore the rest of the house yet because the consent talk was about to start. I got a glass of water with Diego, and a bit of fruit from plates that were laid out on the dining room table. We asked each other about work as we entered a large, dark living room space. There were about 20 chairs in a circle, as if we were about to do a sĂ©ance. Most of the chairs in the circle were full. There were about six single women, three older couples, and a couple of random men. Plus me, Diego, Matt, and whoever else we had met in the kitchen, and that was about it. I recognized one other guy there from my writing group, who I won’t name for obvious reasons.

I sat down, and Diego sat next to me, and Manny started on a 45-minute spiel about what we were and were not allowed to do. He was shirtless and wearing suspenders and small black boxer shorts. A couple of the girls translated into Spanish. He said:

“A play party is an event that’s just like a house party, except that when you go to a house party, the door to the bedroom is closed. If someone hooks up at a house party, they do so privately, behind closed doors. At a play party, the doors to all the bedrooms are open at all times. You are not actually allowed to close the doors, because that’s how things happen that we, as the hosts, can’t control. And I’m here to make sure that everyone has a good time.”

The rules were as follows:

  • No phones allowed during the whole event at all. I really hadn’t touched another human being sexually in months, so I was excited by this chance to get off of my phone and just be present.
  • All the doors to the rooms had to be open at all times.
  • There was also a livestream room for the rest of this play party community in case we wanted to take the experience to a whole new level.
  • No alcohol. Drink water. The use of drugs wasn’t mentioned. This turned out to be a game-changer for me at this event compared to the previous play parties I attended, and it enabled me to actually enjoy the moment. It’s easy to feel nervous and want to self-medicate or self-lubricate with substances so that you don’t have to sit in your discomfort. But I highly recommend you don’t take any substances at all if you go to a play party. If you numb your feelings with substances, you’ll also numb your joy and positive feelings of being present with a new lover. Plus, watching people have sex can be pretty intoxicating in and of itself.
  • Ask every single time you want to escalate any sexual situation in any way, from kissing to touching to more. If you asked someone, for example, “Can I kiss you?” and they said no, you were not allowed to ask that question again for the rest of the night. I was grateful for this because I didn’t really want to be pestered or pressured to do anything multiple times.
  • Read the room and see whether it made sense to ask to get involved with people who were already doing stuff together. If you were not part of whatever was going on, you had to stand away from the bed along the walls, and simply observe without commenting or interfering.
  • If someone does not say yes enthusiastically, it’s a no.
  • Condoms, towels, and (I believe) lube would be provided in every room.

I was grateful for this talk, even though it was long, because all the rules helped me feel safer. Once the more serious part of the talk was over, Manny asked if anyone wanted to share their vision for what their “mildest” or “wildest” night might look like. I was way too nervous to share anything, and already my personal insecurities were starting to act up. Diego was sitting right next to me, but didn’t seem to be starting much conversation or trying to get my attention in any way. I started to doubt whether he was actually interested in me.

What made me feel even more awkward during the consent talk was that two other girls and the Mexican guy in the dinosaur suit had already started fooling around, with one girl being idolized in the center. They may have been getting off on the fact that we were watching them, but it was really quite distracting during the talk. Still, things started to get interesting as individuals shared their fantasies and ideas for their “mildest” and “wildest” nights. I picked off most of the rest of my chipped manicure during their sharing; I was so nervous about whether Diego was into me. It was clear to me from the toys the other women had brought and what they were wearing that many of them were seasoned play party attendees. Unsurprisingly, these women felt more comfortable sharing what they really wanted with the group:

“I want someone to massage my feet.” (A woman)

“I want someone to whip me until I cry.” (A woman)

“I want a harem of 7 women all over me.” (A man)

“I want to give someone a massage.” (A man, and a couple of other people).

“My wife and I are looking for a third woman that we can spoil.” (A gentleman in his mid-60s).

It surprised me that people were just as willing to give as they were to receive. It got me thinking about how reciprocity in a circle like this really works, and how someone’s pleasure could be heightened by doing stuff to other people. So that was cool.

At this point, the consent talk was over, and the circle of people sitting around began to break up. Many people went upstairs to explore the different rooms. Diego didn’t immediately get up, and we kept chatting for a bit, but I did tell him I needed to go to the bathroom and asked him to wait for me. I went to the bathroom, and he was waiting for me, but then I forgot my phone by the sink, and by the time I returned, he had left. I can’t quite remember how I found him again, but soon, Diego and I climbed the stairs together. He was hanging out with me, or maybe I was hanging out with him. Either way, I had no interest in facing this party alone, and him being there was reassuring. It was nice to have someone to witness the party with.

In the first room we entered upstairs, we watched a girl, Betty, getting fisted by her male partner. If I remember correctly, they were on some kind of large recliner chair in the corner, and she was down on all fours like a cat, spread out on his lap, while he sat in the chair. He was putting more of his fingers inside of her, or at least inside her vagina as far as I could see. She had Halloween makeup on, like Alice Cooper, and she seemed to be really enjoying herself. Her partner was enjoying it also. They seemed to be counting fingers together.

Diego and I stood at the end of the room together, just watching. And it was hot. Betty and her partner ended up beckoning us closer. I was hesitant to get too close. It seemed like a pretty private thing they were doing, and I didn’t want to interrupt them. But Betty seemed to kind of enjoy us being there and witnessing her. We stood only a couple of feet away, just watching.

As you know, I’ve watched a lot of porn in my life, and so I know that I do enjoy watching other people have sex. And watching it in person was very intense, but enjoyable. It’s weird because as the voyeur, you’re like an active observer. You’re allowed to watch, but then you’re just kind of standing there with your arms folded, leaning against a wall, like you’re observing animals in a play pen. It’s weird. But it’s also safer that way.

At that moment, the amazing words of Miriam Margolyes came into my mind, from a story she told about meeting Laurence Olivier: I started to cream in my knickers. Hah! Wow. I can’t believe I get to write sentences like this. Watching Betty have sex and be really turned on really started to turn me on. The horniness and lack of inhibitions that you might get from drinking alcohol began to cloud my better judgment, even if I was stone-cold sober.  

Diego and I went into the next room. In there, on a double bed, an older couple (who seemed to be in their 50s or 60s) were sharing one of the girls, who had said she liked massages and foot rubs, and the man was massaging her. His partner was also hooking up with another guy and a girl who was wearing some leather panties and a leather bra that had no cups, so her boobs were just out. That was my favorite outfit of the night, by far. She also had her hair in a beautiful, long braid. So there were five of them on the bed in total. We watched the older man rub the girl’s feet, massage her boobs, and pin her neck down. It was crazy to watch because the girl’s body was shaking, like she was having multiple orgasms, and she seemed to be loving it.

At that moment, Manny, the host, came in and leaned against the chest of drawers next to me. He asked me what my mildest and wildest night would be. I could feel my PTSD just below the surface of everything, but it didn’t feel activated. I was mostly worried about being propositioned by someone I didn’t want to hook up with, and about that being awkward and preventing me from having fun with people I did want to hook up with somehow. Aside from that, I was horny as fuck, and determined to break my celibacy streak. I told Manny my truth at that moment:

“I’m enjoying watching other people have sex right now, so if I just do that, that’s okay. That’s probably my mildest night. My wildest night is that I’d like to have sex, but that depends on whether I can find a partner who I want to do that with.”

My answer sounded very vanilla, but it also felt like a bit of a relief to say it out loud. Unfortunately, as I said it standing next to Diego, my insecurities started to get the better of me. Diego and I had been casually hanging out up until this point, but I could feel my wounded inner child start to attach to him in that deeply insecure way. I’ve been working on this in therapy for years, and in my 12-step program for dysfunctional families, called ACA. I know Diego will be reading this as well (hi, Diego!), but my priority is to be as honest as possible here. My inner child often latches onto the man I’m closest to, wanting to be rescued. I’m sure it has to do with being angrily rejected by my father repeatedly at a young age. It sounds weird, but my inner child cannot tell the difference between a random man I want attention from and my father. It makes me all self-critical, so I squash myself down and don’t risk asking for what I want. Diego was also a free agent, who could roam around the party as much as he wanted to. We weren’t even dating.

In some ways, you have to be prepared to face your childhood demons and insecurities when you go to a play party. New sexual experiences can aggravate old wounds, yet I’m pretty sure this is totally normal. Luckily, as challenging as it was, I had my tools ready, and I tried to be gentle with myself. For me, that meant speaking with my inner child to make sure she felt loved and safe, especially in those moments where I was fabricating abandonment from a man I had just met. Doing the emotional work like therapy hasn’t stopped me from feeling these things; it’s just helped me recognize patterns so I can cope in those shaky moments.

In that moment, I was attracted to and wanted attention from Diego. Of course, I wish I could be a normal, securely attached person. But as we watched the five people on the bed, and I got the feeling that I wanted to ask Diego if he wanted to make out, I was deeply struggling. The closer I wanted to get to Diego, the more my inner child felt scared and abandoned.

All of a sudden, Diego walked away from me to the other side of the room. He was just getting a closer look at the various group activities unfolding in front of us, I think. But when he walked away from me, my inner child was deeply triggered and sad. This wasn’t a direct rejection, but it felt like one. Then Diego walked out of the room, and my fear went through the roof. I realized I had to do something in that moment. I was going to have to challenge the narrative in my head and push through this. I had to approach him. I was also stressed because now I knew the rules of consent, and I could only ask Diego once if he wanted to hook up. If he said no, I figured I would just leave the party because there was no one else that I was truly interested in hooking up with, and my inner child had already been through enough.

Challenging all my darkest narratives of shame and abandonment, I ran out of the room to follow him. Out on the landing, I saw him walking down the stairs.

“Hey!” I shouted and caught up with him. Diego stopped and turned around. “Are you leaving? I was hoping
uh
wondering if you wanted to do some stuff together.”

“Sure,” he said, “I was just going to get some water—”

“Oh! Got it. Go ahead,” I said. I suddenly noticed I was holding an empty cup. “Do you think you could get me some?”

“Sure,” he said. He took my cup and continued down the stairs.

I walked back into the whipping room, letting out an audible sigh of relief. As I watched these girls get their bare asses whipped with leather tassels, I couldn’t believe that I had managed to push through my entire wounded inner child’s script and ask for what I wanted. Now I was in a totally different position: Diego had agreed that he wanted to do “stuff” with me, whatever that meant, and he was also getting me some water. For me, this was a huge success in my journey to becoming shamelessly sexy. Even if it scared the hell out of me, I had to ask for what I wanted if I had any hope of getting my needs met. This situation was not the same as my childhood terrors, even if my inner child didn’t know the difference.

When Diego came back upstairs, he handed me the water, and we sipped from our cups together as we watched more of the girls getting their asses whipped. Now that I felt reassured by him, I loved that there was really no rush at this party and we could all take our time on a tech-free evening. I didn’t need to be anywhere. If I was standing in the whipping room and enjoying watching people getting whipped, I could just stay there. There was no need to move quickly or anywhere to progress to. There’s something really refreshing about not being in a rush and just being present. When I was in doubt, I could just stay quiet and observe.

Diego and I turned to each other soon after, and he asked me if he could kiss me (I think), and I said yes. Soon, we were making out pretty full-on in the middle of the landing between the two rooms. This making out was the highlight of the night for me. I felt desired and excited. There was so much to explore. Anticipation was skyrocketing, and things were just heating up.

We slipped into the group sex room, out of the way of the flow of people, and made out there. Diego felt up my dress’s skirt, and he started to grab my ass, but then it was clear that he wanted me to take off my dress, and coming at the dress from both top and bottom wasn’t really working.

“Do you want to find somewhere a bit more horizontal?” I said, and he agreed, and so we found another room of single beds at the back of the house. One of the single beds had a towel on it (who knows if it was clean), so we quickly flung it aside and started making out on top of the covers of one of the single beds. I knew we were going to do whatever we wanted to each other, but it was also weird because the door was open and anyone who wanted to could come in and out. And that’s also part of the deal.

We started making out. We took off each other’s clothes. And at one point not long after that, he asked if he could eat me out. I said yes, obviously. I had pretty recently shaved my vagine (my preferred way to say it) and been exercising a decent amount. I knew I looked good. With some prior thought, I definitely would have worn some sexier underwear, or a cute slutty outfit, though I was comfortable and also felt sexy in the red dress I wore there.

I remember just a wash of a couple of faces. Some people came in, some people came out. I didn’t really feel that much shame about it. Since I had just watched Betty get fisted, Matt get whipped, and the older dude almost give a girl an orgasm just from touching her feet, I didn’t really care if a couple of people saw Diego eating me out. I thought I would have felt more of something, like getting turned on knowing other people were watching, but I think that ultimately I’m not as much of an exhibitionist as I thought I was. Or at least, I’m an exhibitionist with my partner, who I want to see me naked and love me naked and desire me naked. But other people, I don’t know; I just didn’t really care either way. I kind of got the sense that whatever happened at this party would be behind closed doors, and no one else would kiss and tell (except me, writing for you guys here).

So Diego was eating me out, and that was hot, but then I got a bit bored and fussy, so I got on top of him. I think he felt a lot of pressure, or he wasn’t able to get hard really, even after I asked him,

“Can I touch your penis?” (Ever-continuing with the consent rules) and he said yes, and I gave him somewhat of a lopsided handjob. Looking back, I wish I had done more to pleasure him, but I hope he had a nice time, anyway. I did get a bit of his pre-cum on my hands, and I think we both wanted to have penetrative sex, but it just didn’t work out that way.

My neck with a giant bruise and teeth marks on it
The souvenir I found on my collar bone the day after 😅  Luckily, no one could see it when I was wearing a t-shirt!

Of course, I wish I had brought my Magic Wand, a vibrator, or a butt plug (hemorrhoids aside), because suddenly I was raw-dogging my masturbation with my hand for the first time in months. For future play parties, I will 1000% be bringing my own toys. Diego assisted me somewhat in giving me love bites and biting on my boobs, which I always enjoy. But again, this was our first time hooking up, and we barely knew each other, so if I wanted to come, I was going to have to mostly do it myself.

I told him about my praise kink, and how I wanted him to call me a good girl and count down from 10 to give me a sense of performance anxiety, like performing on a test at my academically rigorous high school. He obliged, which was nice of him. He choked me a bit too, which was great. I had one strong, full-on, earth-shattering orgasm that lasted for a good 30 seconds.

After I climaxed, I looked up. Matt was sitting beside the edge of the bed, looking at me. He was still wearing his bear onesie, surprisingly. I think I smiled at him. It felt like a strangely full-circle moment. The guy who had invited me to the party, witnessing my orgasm with my vagina displayed out for everyone to see. But somehow, I just didn’t give a fuck. I’d seen him get spanked senseless in the whipping room some 30 minutes earlier. I smiled at him in acknowledgment, from one kinky person to another.

After I orgasmed with Diego, we made out more and chatted for a bit. He had some really cute tattoos that I enjoyed, and at one point we put on our underwear and explored the house a bit more together, including in the group sex room again.

The people who had been massaging each other earlier were now broadly fucking and pleasuring each other. The older man who had been massaging the younger woman’s feet came up to me. He turned to me and asked,

“Would you like a massage?”

“No, but thank you for the kind offer,” I said, fearing that I was about to be dragged down a slippery slope I had no interest in riding. I felt less proud of being asked, and more afraid. Luckily, the older man respected my wishes and didn’t press me or ask me again.

At some point, Diego and I went downstairs to get some water and some chapstick. After hopping from room to room together, we ended up back in the bed together, under the covers this time because it was getting cold.

We started talking. I was attracted to him, and still am. We had a scary amount in common, and I would have liked to get to know him more. But a couple of things came up in our conversation that gave me pause. The biggest elephant in the room was that he now mentioned his long-distance girlfriend in Poland, basically halfway around the world. He was even learning Polish so he could communicate with her mother. It was a sweet thing to say, if not a bit jarring to hear, but it helped me quickly recalibrate the experience we had just had in my mind.

Here I was, wrapped naked around a stranger, vibing, flirting, teasing, laughing. When he mentioned his girlfriend, of course I assumed they had agreed to be open, whoever she was. I have never aspired to be a home wrecker. It’s just not my vibe. Still, it narrowed the scope of my intended interactions with him pretty significantly. He owed me nothing. I owed him less of my time, my body, my attention. We were basically having a spicy one-night-stand. I had already orgasmed and gotten my fill, in a sense. And yet, despite being at an open sex party, I still felt a strange sense of ownership over him, which I’m pretty sure I was not supposed to feel.

I thought we were getting along great. Still, he made it abundantly clear to me when he said,

“I don’t want anything romantic with you.”

Point taken, I thought to myself. I have learned the hard way to let a man tell you who he is, and this time I was going to listen. I took a mental note and would have written it down. Still, it was a pity to hear this from someone who I felt intellectually and sexually compatible with. Yet once he started mentioning other previous girlfriends, I noticed a faint pattern in his past footsteps. I thought back to a bunch of cautionary reels I had consumed on Instagram, and the central theme of the lesbian movie, “Blue Is the Warmest Color.” I heard a voice loud and clear inside of me:

How you meet him is how he will leave you.

Deep in hypotheticals in my mind, this was a word of caution to myself. Ignoring my feelings, channeling logic, I knew that if we ever dated and happened to live in different cities, there was nothing stopping him from going to another play party, meeting another girl of his choosing, falling for her, and leaving me. The end of our imaginary relationship flashed before my eyes.

It was getting late, 1:30am or so. Diego said he wanted to keep in touch because he wanted to have penetrative sex with me. I agreed I would like that as well someday, and we talked vague logistics of where either of us would be; me, relocating more to Los Angeles, and him, working from New York. I told him I was visiting friends in New York that week, but it turned out his dates didn’t overlap.

The last thing we did together was stop by the whipping room, where we watched an interesting threesome play out. The Mexican guy who had been in the dinosaur costume was lying down with one girl sitting on top of him, fucking, while he also was intent on making another girl cum with his hands. It was clear from watching them that Diego’s and my level of sexual intensity in the moment was zero in comparison. At that point, I kind of felt tired by it. I asked Diego what he liked about it. He said it was because the guy was pleasuring both women at once. Interesting, I thought to myself. But I was beyond the point of wanting to join in or hype myself up again.

When we got downstairs, a number of people were sitting around, clothed and chatting. It was a bit strange to see them preparing to leave, as if we were all stepping out of this world of pure sexual openness, and back into “real life”. But I had had fun. Diego and I exchanged Instagrams with the vague plan to meet up at some point at another play party. He ended up walking me outside and making sure I got into my Uber, which was sweet of him. He wasn’t quite ready to leave the party, and in hindsight, I hope he explored more and met some new sexual partners. But I wasn’t ready to see him hook up with other people, and I was ready for bed. Despite many years of therapy and ACA work, learning how to be my own loving parent, there was only so much that my inner child could handle.

Even though I had faced all of Diego’s truths, talking about his girlfriend, not wanting anything romantic with me, and accepting our positions as each other’s temporary sexual playthings, I still felt it would hurt my feelings to see him hook up or make out with someone else. There may have also been a hormonal point at play here: I was ending my period and starting ovulation soon (I have a very short cycle), and so my biology was obviously telling me to trap his ass so that he could get me pregnant asap. That’s just how my body speaks to me sometimes, and it dresses up that biological need with all kinds of weird self-criticisms and attempts to control the situation, to help me get what I need.

I reflected on what non-monogamy meant to me. While I wanted to have other lovers in other cities, with Diego I just wanted to experience his devotion in the moment. I could be happy with my partner hooking up with other people in front of me if I felt safe enough, and honestly, I hadn’t felt totally safe with Diego in that sense. Maybe it was because of the signals he gave me, or because I had just met him, or because my inner child was so activated. But if I was with a partner who I knew worshipped me and was fully committed, I think I’d be a lot less concerned with them playing with other people. It’s a push and pull thing: the less attentive my partner is, the more I feel I need them and tug harder, and I want to limit their sexual interaction with other people, because I don’t feel tended to. I guess my body could pick up through his actions that his intentions were for short-term fun, rather than sticking around.

In the Uber ride home, I felt a bit sad. I had had such a crappy year. Maybe if I had gotten on Feeld earlier, I wouldn’t have felt so alone or been so celibate for so long. Of course, when I was really depressed, I didn’t want to have sex. But the event as a whole made me feel like sex was fun, accessible, and easy to find. I was sad not to have found a boyfriend like Diego, who is smart, curious, and capable. Now I was leaving Mexico City for a few months, and I had missed that opportunity to date someone seriously in the last two years.

Overall, I’m extremely happy I went to the play party. I wasn’t attracted to everyone, and I found the larger group sex activities very intimidating. But it was nice to be in a place where people were allowed to explore sex in the ways they wanted to and express themselves. I could definitely see myself attending a play party again, and while I got lucky finding a spontaneous partner at this one, part of me knew it would have been more fun to attend with a partner I knew better.

Most of all, I’m really proud of myself for challenging my inner child’s scared, critical narrative at a moment when I was deep in my self-criticism and pain from my old wounds. I went right up to Diego and asked him if he wanted to do stuff together. And then, when he agreed, he even went to fetch me some water. That was huge for me. On my journey to being shamelessly sexy that night, I had to overcome far more than I was expecting to simply ask for what I wanted. I had to dig through years of old shit, old systems, and crooked narratives about myself to simply use my voice. And for that, I feel proud and grateful to myself for pushing through.

Read about my other kinky adventures from Feeld in “The Strangest Date I Ever Went On and “The Dog Cage.”

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to read more of my work and follow my journey...

Night At The Play Party 😈

The photo above is not from the party itself, but very much matches the vibe.

This article is the extended version of the soon-to-be-published “How to Attend A Play Party
And Actually Enjoy It 😏,” with absolutely all the details. Enjoy!

On a Saturday night in November, I headed to my 4th play party ever. I stepped out of my Uber into the fresh night air and reached the gate of a barely marked house in Las Lomas, one of the fanciest neighborhoods in Mexico City. It was 10:40pm, and I was relieved there had been so little traffic: I had to attend a mandatory consent discussion at 11pm, before the real party got started.

Still, I was nervous as heck. My first three play party experiences in New York City had ended in vomiting, shame, and disaster. I’d gotten way too drunk way too quickly, and taken a giant edible I shouldn’t have, in an attempt to avoid my feelings, which ended up majorly backfiring. I’d had to shuffle myself quickly into getaway Ubers soon after I arrived before I made a total fool of myself. Would this play party turn out to be just as bad? Would my PTSD (caused by a nasty sexual assault I experienced five years ago) be triggered again? There was only one way to find out. I punched the secret code into the pinpad. The gate buzzed open, and I stepped inside.

Like many of my good, sexy stories, this one started on the kink app, Feeld. I got invited to this party kind of by accident. I had been on and off Feeld for years, but something made me redownload it. Things were finally turning around for the better in my life. I was getting over depression from my grandmother's death and going into debt. I was about to leave Mexico City for a trip that would last three and a half months. This was my last weekend in the city, and part of me wanted to do something crazy. I also hadn’t had penetrative sex in over a year, and I had only had one partner who ate me out about six months ago, and I was tiptoeing on the particularly horny cusp between the end of my period and ovulating, leaving me extra energized. Most of all, I have been numbing myself by scrolling on the internet for so long that I needed to put myself out there.

After a couple of matches on Feeld, I stumbled across an acquaintance from my circle of Tuluminati friends in Mexico City, whom I’ll call Matt. Matt, as far as I knew, was in an open marriage, but the few times I had hung out with him, I got the sense he was an intriguing weirdo. Plus, I thought he was cute. However, he had never seemed interested in me. He had the creative, psychedelic air of a regular Burning Man attendee, a group of people I regularly hung out with in Mexico City but deny being identified with. When I came across Matt’s profile on Feeld, I thought: fuck it! I swiped right. We matched a day later, and this is the gist of our conversation:

Matt: Hi

Me: Hi

Matt: How are you?

Me: I’m good. I just finished playing pickleball. What’s up?

Matt: Fun. I play padel. I’m going to a play party tonight.

Me: A play party? Is that an open invite?

Matt: Text this guy. [Shares guy’s phone number.] It’s going to be a big one. About 60-70 people.

These messages happened over the course of a few hours, between me going to pickleball and back, and feeling all the sad, giddy anxiety of a guy I might be interested in not messaging me back promptly. I now had to make a decision. Matt had, indeed, invited me to this play party. I did find him attractive, and I was potentially curious to hook up with him. But if I was going to go to this party, I also didn’t want to anchor myself on the expectation that we would hook up, or even that he would be attracted to me. I assured myself that if we didn’t make out, I wasn’t going to beat myself up about it. The success of my night would not hinge on him (and that turned out to be a great decision). Still, I had a birthday party to attend earlier in the night, and a bunch of other saying-goodbye things planned. Should I go or not? It was also a costume party, the week after Halloween, so there was that to consider.

Still unsure whether to go, I got dressed up in an outfit I thought might be appropriate. It wasn’t a Halloween costume, but I did wear something that was both striking and comfortable and made me feel sexy. I showed up in all red: deep-red lipstick, boots, a handbag, and a dress with metal buttons down the middle that showed off my curves.

When I got to the Ecobici station to hop on a bike to go to the birthday party, I checked out the play party’s website. It had lots of flashing emojis and text in capital letters, and a giant ticker clock that would expire in the next 45 minutes if I didn’t buy my ticket on time. I decided to wait for a little while longer.

The flyer for the play party
The actual flyer for the event, with all the identifiable details covered!

As I put on my helmet at the Ecobici station, I heard a couple of people walking down the street. Of course, I was living in Condesa, so it wasn’t completely unusual to hear someone speak English. But this  woman had a West London accent, very close to where I am from. And she seemed to be about 70 years old. And I thought to myself: one day I’ll be too old to go to one of these play parties. I may never be this hot or this young ever again. In fact, when I ended up at the play party, there were plenty of slightly older couples around her age. So I maybe took the age thing too seriously. Still, I think there is something to be said about the fact that this body in this lifetime isn’t going to last forever. Plus, I needed something to write about on my blog.

My friends at the birthday party told me I looked great, which was a lovely stroke of the ego. In my Uber on the way to the party, I bought my ticket and texted the guy, Manny, who was hosting the play party. I joined a WhatsApp group of a couple hundred people of the play community around the world, and Manny encouraged me to introduce myself in the group. I decided not to do that; I’m not sure why. During this journey, I remember we drove past a shop for children’s christening outfits that was closed for the night. I chuckled to myself. The store itself looked so innocent and somewhat religious. Here I was, about to do things that might be considered immoral to the customers of that store.

When I arrived at the house, a couple of girls were chatting in Spanish outside, and I found a bathroom next to the garage, where I freshened up. Unfortunately, I was in the middle of a pretty nasty hemorrhoid flare, which is maybe TMI, and sadly meant that I would not be doing any butt stuff. I was also feeling pretty nervous, but I made some big poses in the mirror to try to beef up my confidence. I just had to trust the process and let things play out.

I entered the house through the side door and entered the small kitchen. Inside were two short, plump women wearing corsets, black lingerie, and hosiery. There were also two Mexican men and Matt, my match from Feeld, who was wearing a bear onesie. I felt extremely awkward, but I was not quite ready to explore the rest of the house, so I got chatting. One of the Mexican guys was dressed up in a dinosaur costume, and the other was wearing a hoodie.

Things started to get weird pretty quickly. Another girl entered the room holding a colorful leather whip with tassels, and she offered to spank or whip someone. I declined, but Matt agreed immediately. So before I had hardly walked in the door, Matt bent over in his bear onesie, and I watched him get whipped on his ass right in front of me. As someone who is more submissive myself, I wasn’t that turned on watching him, much less because I was a bit shocked. The Mexican guy in the dinosaur onesie was cuter to begin with, but he now had the two girls in the corsets on either of his arms, and they were already making out. I turned to the other Mexican guy in the hoodie and started to make polite conversation. Mostly just because I felt awkward.

The guy in the hoodie’s name was Diego. He seemed interesting, intelligent, and if anything, pretty nerdy. Just how I like them. He had glasses, long curly hair, and tattoos. He met my threshold of attractiveness, but I wasn’t overly enamored with him when I first met him. He seemed like the kind of person I could become more attracted to over time, if we got to know each other more intimately.

We didn’t have any time to explore the rest of the house yet because the consent talk was about to start. I got a glass of water with Diego, and a bit of fruit from plates that were laid out on the dining room table. We asked each other about work as we entered a large, dark living room space. There were about 20 chairs in a circle, as if we were about to do a sĂ©ance. Most of the chairs in the circle were full. There were about six single women, three older couples, and a couple of random men. Plus me, Diego, Matt, and whoever else we had met in the kitchen, and that was about it. I recognized one other guy there from my writing group, who I won’t name for obvious reasons.

I sat down, and Diego sat next to me, and Manny started on a 45-minute spiel about what we were and were not allowed to do. He was shirtless and wearing suspenders and small black boxer shorts. A couple of the girls translated into Spanish. He said:

“A play party is an event that’s just like a house party, except that when you go to a house party, the door to the bedroom is closed. If someone hooks up at a house party, they do so privately, behind closed doors. At a play party, the doors to all the bedrooms are open at all times. You are not actually allowed to close the doors, because that’s how things happen that we, as the hosts, can’t control. And I’m here to make sure that everyone has a good time.”

The rules were as follows:

  • No phones allowed during the whole event at all. I really hadn’t touched another human being sexually in months, so I was excited by this chance to get off of my phone and just be present.
  • All the doors to the rooms had to be open at all times.
  • There was also a livestream room for the rest of this play party community in case we wanted to take the experience to a whole new level.
  • No alcohol. Drink water. The use of drugs wasn’t mentioned. This turned out to be a game-changer for me at this event compared to the previous play parties I attended, and it enabled me to actually enjoy the moment. It’s easy to feel nervous and want to self-medicate or self-lubricate with substances so that you don’t have to sit in your discomfort. But I highly recommend you don’t take any substances at all if you go to a play party. If you numb your feelings with substances, you’ll also numb your joy and positive feelings of being present with a new lover. Plus, watching people have sex can be pretty intoxicating in and of itself.
  • Ask every single time you want to escalate any sexual situation in any way, from kissing to touching to more. If you asked someone, for example, “Can I kiss you?” and they said no, you were not allowed to ask that question again for the rest of the night. I was grateful for this because I didn’t really want to be pestered or pressured to do anything multiple times.
  • Read the room and see whether it made sense to ask to get involved with people who were already doing stuff together. If you were not part of whatever was going on, you had to stand away from the bed along the walls, and simply observe without commenting or interfering.
  • If someone does not say yes enthusiastically, it’s a no.
  • Condoms, towels, and (I believe) lube would be provided in every room.

I was grateful for this talk, even though it was long, because all the rules helped me feel safer. Once the more serious part of the talk was over, Manny asked if anyone wanted to share their vision for what their “mildest” or “wildest” night might look like. I was way too nervous to share anything, and already my personal insecurities were starting to act up. Diego was sitting right next to me, but didn’t seem to be starting much conversation or trying to get my attention in any way. I started to doubt whether he was actually interested in me.

What made me feel even more awkward during the consent talk was that two other girls and the Mexican guy in the dinosaur suit had already started fooling around, with one girl being idolized in the center. They may have been getting off on the fact that we were watching them, but it was really quite distracting during the talk. Still, things started to get interesting as individuals shared their fantasies and ideas for their “mildest” and “wildest” nights. I picked off most of the rest of my chipped manicure during their sharing; I was so nervous about whether Diego was into me. It was clear to me from the toys the other women had brought and what they were wearing that many of them were seasoned play party attendees. Unsurprisingly, these women felt more comfortable sharing what they really wanted with the group:

“I want someone to massage my feet.” (A woman)

“I want someone to whip me until I cry.” (A woman)

“I want a harem of 7 women all over me.” (A man)

“I want to give someone a massage.” (A man, and a couple of other people).

“My wife and I are looking for a third woman that we can spoil.” (A gentleman in his mid-60s).

It surprised me that people were just as willing to give as they were to receive. It got me thinking about how reciprocity in a circle like this really works, and how someone’s pleasure could be heightened by doing stuff to other people. So that was cool.

At this point, the consent talk was over, and the circle of people sitting around began to break up. Many people went upstairs to explore the different rooms. Diego didn’t immediately get up, and we kept chatting for a bit, but I did tell him I needed to go to the bathroom and asked him to wait for me. I went to the bathroom, and he was waiting for me, but then I forgot my phone by the sink, and by the time I returned, he had left. I can’t quite remember how I found him again, but soon, Diego and I climbed the stairs together. He was hanging out with me, or maybe I was hanging out with him. Either way, I had no interest in facing this party alone, and him being there was reassuring. It was nice to have someone to witness the party with.

In the first room we entered upstairs, we watched a girl, Betty, getting fisted by her male partner. If I remember correctly, they were on some kind of large recliner chair in the corner, and she was down on all fours like a cat, spread out on his lap, while he sat in the chair. He was putting more of his fingers inside of her, or at least inside her vagina as far as I could see. She had Halloween makeup on, like Alice Cooper, and she seemed to be really enjoying herself. Her partner was enjoying it also. They seemed to be counting fingers together.

Diego and I stood at the end of the room together, just watching. And it was hot. Betty and her partner ended up beckoning us closer. I was hesitant to get too close. It seemed like a pretty private thing they were doing, and I didn’t want to interrupt them. But Betty seemed to kind of enjoy us being there and witnessing her. We stood only a couple of feet away, just watching.

As you know, I’ve watched a lot of porn in my life, and so I know that I do enjoy watching other people have sex. And watching it in person was very intense, but enjoyable. It’s weird because as the voyeur, you’re like an active observer. You’re allowed to watch, but then you’re just kind of standing there with your arms folded, leaning against a wall, like you’re observing animals in a play pen. It’s weird. But it’s also safer that way.

At that moment, the amazing words of Miriam Margolyes came into my mind, from a story she told about meeting Laurence Olivier: I started to cream in my knickers. Hah! Wow. I can’t believe I get to write sentences like this. Watching Betty have sex and be really turned on really started to turn me on. The horniness and lack of inhibitions that you might get from drinking alcohol began to cloud my better judgment, even if I was stone-cold sober.  

Diego and I went into the next room. In there, on a double bed, an older couple (who seemed to be in their 50s or 60s) were sharing one of the girls, who had said she liked massages and foot rubs, and the man was massaging her. His partner was also hooking up with another guy and a girl who was wearing some leather panties and a leather bra that had no cups, so her boobs were just out. That was my favorite outfit of the night, by far. She also had her hair in a beautiful, long braid. So there were five of them on the bed in total. We watched the older man rub the girl’s feet, massage her boobs, and pin her neck down. It was crazy to watch because the girl’s body was shaking, like she was having multiple orgasms, and she seemed to be loving it.

At that moment, Manny, the host, came in and leaned against the chest of drawers next to me. He asked me what my mildest and wildest night would be. I could feel my PTSD just below the surface of everything, but it didn’t feel activated. I was mostly worried about being propositioned by someone I didn’t want to hook up with, and about that being awkward and preventing me from having fun with people I did want to hook up with somehow. Aside from that, I was horny as fuck, and determined to break my celibacy streak. I told Manny my truth at that moment:

“I’m enjoying watching other people have sex right now, so if I just do that, that’s okay. That’s probably my mildest night. My wildest night is that I’d like to have sex, but that depends on whether I can find a partner who I want to do that with.”

My answer sounded very vanilla, but it also felt like a bit of a relief to say it out loud. Unfortunately, as I said it standing next to Diego, my insecurities started to get the better of me. Diego and I had been casually hanging out up until this point, but I could feel my wounded inner child start to attach to him in that deeply insecure way. I’ve been working on this in therapy for years, and in my 12-step program for dysfunctional families, called ACA. I know Diego will be reading this as well (hi, Diego!), but my priority is to be as honest as possible here. My inner child often latches onto the man I’m closest to, wanting to be rescued. I’m sure it has to do with being angrily rejected by my father repeatedly at a young age. It sounds weird, but my inner child cannot tell the difference between a random man I want attention from and my father. It makes me all self-critical, so I squash myself down and don’t risk asking for what I want. Diego was also a free agent, who could roam around the party as much as he wanted to. We weren’t even dating.

In some ways, you have to be prepared to face your childhood demons and insecurities when you go to a play party. New sexual experiences can aggravate old wounds, yet I’m pretty sure this is totally normal. Luckily, as challenging as it was, I had my tools ready, and I tried to be gentle with myself. For me, that meant speaking with my inner child to make sure she felt loved and safe, especially in those moments where I was fabricating abandonment from a man I had just met. Doing the emotional work like therapy hasn’t stopped me from feeling these things; it’s just helped me recognize patterns so I can cope in those shaky moments.

In that moment, I was attracted to and wanted attention from Diego. Of course, I wish I could be a normal, securely attached person. But as we watched the five people on the bed, and I got the feeling that I wanted to ask Diego if he wanted to make out, I was deeply struggling. The closer I wanted to get to Diego, the more my inner child felt scared and abandoned.

All of a sudden, Diego walked away from me to the other side of the room. He was just getting a closer look at the various group activities unfolding in front of us, I think. But when he walked away from me, my inner child was deeply triggered and sad. This wasn’t a direct rejection, but it felt like one. Then Diego walked out of the room, and my fear went through the roof. I realized I had to do something in that moment. I was going to have to challenge the narrative in my head and push through this. I had to approach him. I was also stressed because now I knew the rules of consent, and I could only ask Diego once if he wanted to hook up. If he said no, I figured I would just leave the party because there was no one else that I was truly interested in hooking up with, and my inner child had already been through enough.

Challenging all my darkest narratives of shame and abandonment, I ran out of the room to follow him. Out on the landing, I saw him walking down the stairs.

“Hey!” I shouted and caught up with him. Diego stopped and turned around. “Are you leaving? I was hoping
uh
wondering if you wanted to do some stuff together.”

“Sure,” he said, “I was just going to get some water—”

“Oh! Got it. Go ahead,” I said. I suddenly noticed I was holding an empty cup. “Do you think you could get me some?”

“Sure,” he said. He took my cup and continued down the stairs.

I walked back into the whipping room, letting out an audible sigh of relief. As I watched these girls get their bare asses whipped with leather tassels, I couldn’t believe that I had managed to push through my entire wounded inner child’s script and ask for what I wanted. Now I was in a totally different position: Diego had agreed that he wanted to do “stuff” with me, whatever that meant, and he was also getting me some water. For me, this was a huge success in my journey to becoming shamelessly sexy. Even if it scared the hell out of me, I had to ask for what I wanted if I had any hope of getting my needs met. This situation was not the same as my childhood terrors, even if my inner child didn’t know the difference.

When Diego came back upstairs, he handed me the water, and we sipped from our cups together as we watched more of the girls getting their asses whipped. Now that I felt reassured by him, I loved that there was really no rush at this party and we could all take our time on a tech-free evening. I didn’t need to be anywhere. If I was standing in the whipping room and enjoying watching people getting whipped, I could just stay there. There was no need to move quickly or anywhere to progress to. There’s something really refreshing about not being in a rush and just being present. When I was in doubt, I could just stay quiet and observe.

Diego and I turned to each other soon after, and he asked me if he could kiss me (I think), and I said yes. Soon, we were making out pretty full-on in the middle of the landing between the two rooms. This making out was the highlight of the night for me. I felt desired and excited. There was so much to explore. Anticipation was skyrocketing, and things were just heating up.

We slipped into the group sex room, out of the way of the flow of people, and made out there. Diego felt up my dress’s skirt, and he started to grab my ass, but then it was clear that he wanted me to take off my dress, and coming at the dress from both top and bottom wasn’t really working.

“Do you want to find somewhere a bit more horizontal?” I said, and he agreed, and so we found another room of single beds at the back of the house. One of the single beds had a towel on it (who knows if it was clean), so we quickly flung it aside and started making out on top of the covers of one of the single beds. I knew we were going to do whatever we wanted to each other, but it was also weird because the door was open and anyone who wanted to could come in and out. And that’s also part of the deal.

We started making out. We took off each other’s clothes. And at one point not long after that, he asked if he could eat me out. I said yes, obviously. I had pretty recently shaved my vagine (my preferred way to say it) and been exercising a decent amount. I knew I looked good. With some prior thought, I definitely would have worn some sexier underwear, or a cute slutty outfit, though I was comfortable and also felt sexy in the red dress I wore there.

I remember just a wash of a couple of faces. Some people came in, some people came out. I didn’t really feel that much shame about it. Since I had just watched Betty get fisted, Matt get whipped, and the older dude almost give a girl an orgasm just from touching her feet, I didn’t really care if a couple of people saw Diego eating me out. I thought I would have felt more of something, like getting turned on knowing other people were watching, but I think that ultimately I’m not as much of an exhibitionist as I thought I was. Or at least, I’m an exhibitionist with my partner, who I want to see me naked and love me naked and desire me naked. But other people, I don’t know; I just didn’t really care either way. I kind of got the sense that whatever happened at this party would be behind closed doors, and no one else would kiss and tell (except me, writing for you guys here).

So Diego was eating me out, and that was hot, but then I got a bit bored and fussy, so I got on top of him. I think he felt a lot of pressure, or he wasn’t able to get hard really, even after I asked him,

“Can I touch your penis?” (Ever-continuing with the consent rules) and he said yes, and I gave him somewhat of a lopsided handjob. Looking back, I wish I had done more to pleasure him, but I hope he had a nice time, anyway. I did get a bit of his pre-cum on my hands, and I think we both wanted to have penetrative sex, but it just didn’t work out that way.

My neck with a giant bruise and teeth marks on it
The souvenir I found on my collar bone the day after 😅  Luckily, no one could see it when I was wearing a t-shirt!

Of course, I wish I had brought my Magic Wand, a vibrator, or a butt plug (hemorrhoids aside), because suddenly I was raw-dogging my masturbation with my hand for the first time in months. For future play parties, I will 1000% be bringing my own toys. Diego assisted me somewhat in giving me love bites and biting on my boobs, which I always enjoy. But again, this was our first time hooking up, and we barely knew each other, so if I wanted to come, I was going to have to mostly do it myself.

I told him about my praise kink, and how I wanted him to call me a good girl and count down from 10 to give me a sense of performance anxiety, like performing on a test at my academically rigorous high school. He obliged, which was nice of him. He choked me a bit too, which was great. I had one strong, full-on, earth-shattering orgasm that lasted for a good 30 seconds.

After I climaxed, I looked up. Matt was sitting beside the edge of the bed, looking at me. He was still wearing his bear onesie, surprisingly. I think I smiled at him. It felt like a strangely full-circle moment. The guy who had invited me to the party, witnessing my orgasm with my vagina displayed out for everyone to see. But somehow, I just didn’t give a fuck. I’d seen him get spanked senseless in the whipping room some 30 minutes earlier. I smiled at him in acknowledgment, from one kinky person to another.

After I orgasmed with Diego, we made out more and chatted for a bit. He had some really cute tattoos that I enjoyed, and at one point we put on our underwear and explored the house a bit more together, including in the group sex room again.

The people who had been massaging each other earlier were now broadly fucking and pleasuring each other. The older man who had been massaging the younger woman’s feet came up to me. He turned to me and asked,

“Would you like a massage?”

“No, but thank you for the kind offer,” I said, fearing that I was about to be dragged down a slippery slope I had no interest in riding. I felt less proud of being asked, and more afraid. Luckily, the older man respected my wishes and didn’t press me or ask me again.

At some point, Diego and I went downstairs to get some water and some chapstick. After hopping from room to room together, we ended up back in the bed together, under the covers this time because it was getting cold.

We started talking. I was attracted to him, and still am. We had a scary amount in common, and I would have liked to get to know him more. But a couple of things came up in our conversation that gave me pause. The biggest elephant in the room was that he now mentioned his long-distance girlfriend in Poland, basically halfway around the world. He was even learning Polish so he could communicate with her mother. It was a sweet thing to say, if not a bit jarring to hear, but it helped me quickly recalibrate the experience we had just had in my mind.

Here I was, wrapped naked around a stranger, vibing, flirting, teasing, laughing. When he mentioned his girlfriend, of course I assumed they had agreed to be open, whoever she was. I have never aspired to be a home wrecker. It’s just not my vibe. Still, it narrowed the scope of my intended interactions with him pretty significantly. He owed me nothing. I owed him less of my time, my body, my attention. We were basically having a spicy one-night-stand. I had already orgasmed and gotten my fill, in a sense. And yet, despite being at an open sex party, I still felt a strange sense of ownership over him, which I’m pretty sure I was not supposed to feel.

I thought we were getting along great. Still, he made it abundantly clear to me when he said,

“I don’t want anything romantic with you.”

Point taken, I thought to myself. I have learned the hard way to let a man tell you who he is, and this time I was going to listen. I took a mental note and would have written it down. Still, it was a pity to hear this from someone who I felt intellectually and sexually compatible with. Yet once he started mentioning other previous girlfriends, I noticed a faint pattern in his past footsteps. I thought back to a bunch of cautionary reels I had consumed on Instagram, and the central theme of the lesbian movie, “Blue Is the Warmest Color.” I heard a voice loud and clear inside of me:

How you meet him is how he will leave you.

Deep in hypotheticals in my mind, this was a word of caution to myself. Ignoring my feelings, channeling logic, I knew that if we ever dated and happened to live in different cities, there was nothing stopping him from going to another play party, meeting another girl of his choosing, falling for her, and leaving me. The end of our imaginary relationship flashed before my eyes.

It was getting late, 1:30am or so. Diego said he wanted to keep in touch because he wanted to have penetrative sex with me. I agreed I would like that as well someday, and we talked vague logistics of where either of us would be; me, relocating more to Los Angeles, and him, working from New York. I told him I was visiting friends in New York that week, but it turned out his dates didn’t overlap.

The last thing we did together was stop by the whipping room, where we watched an interesting threesome play out. The Mexican guy who had been in the dinosaur costume was lying down with one girl sitting on top of him, fucking, while he also was intent on making another girl cum with his hands. It was clear from watching them that Diego’s and my level of sexual intensity in the moment was zero in comparison. At that point, I kind of felt tired by it. I asked Diego what he liked about it. He said it was because the guy was pleasuring both women at once. Interesting, I thought to myself. But I was beyond the point of wanting to join in or hype myself up again.

When we got downstairs, a number of people were sitting around, clothed and chatting. It was a bit strange to see them preparing to leave, as if we were all stepping out of this world of pure sexual openness, and back into “real life”. But I had had fun. Diego and I exchanged Instagrams with the vague plan to meet up at some point at another play party. He ended up walking me outside and making sure I got into my Uber, which was sweet of him. He wasn’t quite ready to leave the party, and in hindsight, I hope he explored more and met some new sexual partners. But I wasn’t ready to see him hook up with other people, and I was ready for bed. Despite many years of therapy and ACA work, learning how to be my own loving parent, there was only so much that my inner child could handle.

Even though I had faced all of Diego’s truths, talking about his girlfriend, not wanting anything romantic with me, and accepting our positions as each other’s temporary sexual playthings, I still felt it would hurt my feelings to see him hook up or make out with someone else. There may have also been a hormonal point at play here: I was ending my period and starting ovulation soon (I have a very short cycle), and so my biology was obviously telling me to trap his ass so that he could get me pregnant asap. That’s just how my body speaks to me sometimes, and it dresses up that biological need with all kinds of weird self-criticisms and attempts to control the situation, to help me get what I need.

I reflected on what non-monogamy meant to me. While I wanted to have other lovers in other cities, with Diego I just wanted to experience his devotion in the moment. I could be happy with my partner hooking up with other people in front of me if I felt safe enough, and honestly, I hadn’t felt totally safe with Diego in that sense. Maybe it was because of the signals he gave me, or because I had just met him, or because my inner child was so activated. But if I was with a partner who I knew worshipped me and was fully committed, I think I’d be a lot less concerned with them playing with other people. It’s a push and pull thing: the less attentive my partner is, the more I feel I need them and tug harder, and I want to limit their sexual interaction with other people, because I don’t feel tended to. I guess my body could pick up through his actions that his intentions were for short-term fun, rather than sticking around.

In the Uber ride home, I felt a bit sad. I had had such a crappy year. Maybe if I had gotten on Feeld earlier, I wouldn’t have felt so alone or been so celibate for so long. Of course, when I was really depressed, I didn’t want to have sex. But the event as a whole made me feel like sex was fun, accessible, and easy to find. I was sad not to have found a boyfriend like Diego, who is smart, curious, and capable. Now I was leaving Mexico City for a few months, and I had missed that opportunity to date someone seriously in the last two years.

Overall, I’m extremely happy I went to the play party. I wasn’t attracted to everyone, and I found the larger group sex activities very intimidating. But it was nice to be in a place where people were allowed to explore sex in the ways they wanted to and express themselves. I could definitely see myself attending a play party again, and while I got lucky finding a spontaneous partner at this one, part of me knew it would have been more fun to attend with a partner I knew better.

Most of all, I’m really proud of myself for challenging my inner child’s scared, critical narrative at a moment when I was deep in my self-criticism and pain from my old wounds. I went right up to Diego and asked him if he wanted to do stuff together. And then, when he agreed, he even went to fetch me some water. That was huge for me. On my journey to being shamelessly sexy that night, I had to overcome far more than I was expecting to simply ask for what I wanted. I had to dig through years of old shit, old systems, and crooked narratives about myself to simply use my voice. And for that, I feel proud and grateful to myself for pushing through.

Read about my other kinky adventures from Feeld in “The Strangest Date I Ever Went On and “The Dog Cage.”

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to read more of my work!

Latest POSTS